Did the Nine influence Star Trek? A chronology check
The claim is that Roddenberry encoded the Nine into Star Trek — usually into Deep Space Nine. It is the most repeated assertion in this whole subject, and it can be settled with two dates.
Photo by Viliam Kudelka on Pexels
This is the claim that carries the Nine into general conversation: that Gene Roddenberry, having been commissioned to write about them in 1975, went on to encode them into Star Trek. The version you will meet most often points at Star Trek: Deep Space Nine — a title with the word in it, a series about a station beside a wormhole, and non-corporeal beings inside that wormhole who exist outside time.
It is a genuinely good pattern-match. It also fails on chronology, and the failure is not a technicality.
What is documented
Gene Roddenberry died on 24 October 1991. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine premiered on 3 January 1993, more than a year later. The series was created by Rick Berman and Michael Piller, and its development began after Roddenberry’s death.
What was claimed
The strongest form of the claim — that DS9 is a deliberate transmission of the Nine material — requires Roddenberry’s involvement, and he was not involved. That form of the claim is simply false, and it can be retired.
A weaker form survives: that Roddenberry’s exposure to the material in 1975 left traces in his later work generally, and that the ideas circulating in his professional environment reached the franchise indirectly. This version is not refuted by the dates. It is also, in its nature, close to unfalsifiable.
What was added later
The wormhole aliens of DS9 — beings outside linear time who communicate with humans and are treated as gods by a nearby civilisation — are the detail most often cited. The resemblance to the Nine is real.
But resemblance is cheap in this genre. Non-corporeal higher intelligences who guide or test humanity are a staple of science fiction that predates the Nine by decades — they are in the pulps, in Arthur C. Clarke, in Star Trek itself from the original series onward. A shared trope is not a transmission.
What remains unexplained
Nothing, on the strong claim. On the weak claim, the honest answer is that we would need the 1975 screenplay and a great deal more about Roddenberry’s working notes to say anything useful, and neither is available.
What is worth noticing is how durable the DS9 claim is despite being checkable in about ninety seconds. That durability is a fact about how these stories travel, and it is arguably more interesting than the claim itself.
Join the discussion
Still open on this one:
- 01
Did Roddenberry ever refer to the 1975 commission in his own papers?
His archive would answer the weak form of the claim. As far as we can establish, nobody has published a search of it for this purpose.
Be the first to comment
Sources
Open them and check for yourself. Where a record is public, it is linked.
The Stargate Conspiracy
Lynn Picknett and Clive Prince, Little, Brown · 1 Jan 1999 · no public copy located
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine — series premiere, "Emissary"
Paramount Television, first broadcast 3 January 1993 · 3 Jan 1993 · no public copy located
Related
Consciousness
Terminal lucidity: when a destroyed brain briefly works again
People with advanced dementia sometimes become clear, coherent and recognisably themselves shortly before death. It is documented in the medical literature, it happens, and nobody can currently explain it.
Consciousness
Ian Stevenson: forty years collecting children who remember other lives
A university psychiatrist spent his career documenting cases of young children who described a previous life, and checking whether the person they described had existed. He assembled over two thousand. The methodology is the argument.
Near Death Experiences
Pam Reynolds: the most-cited near-death case, and what it turns on
In 1991 a woman undergoing brain surgery under extraordinary conditions reported observing the operation. The surgical circumstances were unusually well documented. Whether she was unconscious at the time she perceived what she described is the whole argument.
Near Death Experiences
Near-death experiences: what the clinical research has established
Millions of people report a consistent set of experiences during cardiac arrest. That consistency is a real finding. What it means is where the argument starts, and hospital studies have been running for thirty years.
0 comments